+90 (850) 302 6000 · We'll call you

Promotions, Discounts and Loyalty: Bringing Guests Back Without Eroding Profit

Discounts bring quick sales but erode profit if left uncontrolled. Here are the promotion types, margin-protecting rules, control of discounts and comps, and simple loyalty ideas.

Promotions, Discounts and Loyalty: Bringing Guests Back Without Eroding Profit

A promotion often starts with the ease of "let's discount and the crowds will come", and the result can be a month where revenue rose but profit fell. A good promotion has a goal, a calculated margin and a measurable end. Loyalty is a different job from discounting: giving guests a reason to come back. This article covers both and then explains how to control discounts and comps. The loyalty ideas are general guidance; among product features, we mention only the discount, comp and combo tools.

Promotion types and their risks

Type Example What it is for Risk to watch
Time-based Lunch menu, discount in quiet hours Filling empty hours Discounting guests who would have come anyway
Basket-based A combo menu, a discount on the second item Raising the average check Pushing a low-margin item
Item-based Launching a new dish, clearing surplus stock Promotion and waste prevention Training guests to expect the discounted price
Guest-based Birthday, return-visit voucher Loyalty Not being able to track it, misuse
Recovery A comp after faulty service Winning back satisfaction Unrecorded, uncontrolled comps

Start the promotion from the margin

  1. Write the goal in one sentence. Filling an empty hour, raising the average check or launching a new dish?
  2. Work out the real price of the discount. A dish that costs 40 and sells at 100 excluding VAT contributes 60. With a 20 per cent discount the price is 80 and the contribution 40. To keep the same total contribution, units sold must rise by half. The figures are hypothetical, but the logic holds: even with a high margin, a discount demands a large increase in volume.
  3. Limit duration and scope. Fix the start and end dates, the outlets, days, hours and items from the beginning.
  4. Control discounts outside the promotion. An extra manual discount given during a promotion breaks the calculation.
  5. Plan the measurement. Choose in advance the indicators you will compare for the two weeks before and after.

Explain the promotion to the team and to guests

  • One page for the team: Which dish, which hour, for whom and how will it be processed? There should be no different readings at the till and on the floor. If you can, define the promotion price in the system: price lists tied to day and hour, and combo menus, remove the need for the waiter to give a manual discount.
  • Plain language for guests: Instead of "20 per cent off", state the condition clearly: on which dishes, at which hours, under what terms. Hiding the condition in small print breeds complaints. Make the promotion visible on the menu and on the QR menu.

Controlling discounts and comps: where is the leak?

The biggest risk of a promotion is the unplanned discount: those given to familiar guests, without a reason written down, with no record of who got how much.

Control point Why it matters How to do it
Discount permission Not everyone should be able to give every discount Separate discount and comp permissions by role; cap the highest allowed amount
Mandatory reason Without a reason there is no audit Make staff pick a reason for discounts and comps; the record goes to the audit trail
Predefined discount types Free percentage entry leads to mistakes and leakage Define frequent discounts as named types
Single-use code Vouchers get shared and reused Coded discount: the code goes to the guest's phone and works only once
Unrecorded comps They distort stock and cost records Post comps on the check as "comp" and enter staff meals as a separate type
Weekly review Habits show up in numbers Review the discount and void/comp/waste reports by authorising user

In adisyus, item and check discounts are applied as a percentage or an amount and their reason goes to the audit record; predefined, named and SMS-coded discounts can be defined. Comps are entered as guest comps or staff meals. The discount report separates manual from coded discounts, and the void, comp and waste report lists every record with reason, authoriser and time.

The VAT and accounting treatment of a promotion tied to a sale and of a comp with no consideration can differ. Put in writing with your accountant how you will classify them.

Simple loyalty ideas

  • A stamp card. Such as "the tenth coffee is on us". Do the maths first: the cost of the free item should stay below the contribution of the items already paid for.
  • A return-visit benefit. A small benefit valid for a limited time after the first visit. A time limit raises the voucher's impact and makes its cost predictable.
  • Privilege, not discount. A secret menu or early access to a new dish makes guests feel special without cutting the price.
  • Corporate and regular customers. House account agreements with companies secure regular orders; write down the credit period and limit in advance.
  • Thanks and feedback. A short thank-you and a request for feedback with the bill costs nothing.

Whichever method you choose, the strongest part of loyalty is the guest being remembered, not the discount itself.

Measure the result

Indicator What to look at
Average check Did it rise or fall with the promotion?
Product mix Which items came forward and how did that affect margin?
Discount amount and rate Was the planned budget exceeded?
Comps and waste Is there unrecorded leakage?
Sales after the promotion Was there a dip when normal prices returned?

If sales fall below the previous level when the promotion ends, the discount pulled demand forward; allow for that in the next plan.

Conclusion

A good promotion is one whose goal, margin and end are fixed from the start, and good loyalty rests more on being remembered than on discounting. Permission, reason and reports give control over discounts and comps. For detailed settings, see Discounts and Comps.

← All articles

Related articles

Meet adisyus

Let us call you for a live walkthrough, or try it free for 1 month.